Opinion: Palestinian return is a right not a dream


Elderly Palestinian man holds a key symbolizing the right of return of Palestinian refugees
May 15, 2018 marked the 70th anniversary of what the Palestinians call the “nakba,” or catastrophe, when hundreds of thousands of people were uprooted during Israel’s creation in 1948. Many Palestinian refugees still hold on to their keys and the dream of return.


The BADIL Resource Center for Palestinian Residency and Refugee Rights writes a letter in response to remarks by Swiss foreign affairs minister Ignazio Cassis that cast United Nations aid work for Palestinian refugees as a stumbling block to peace in the Middle East.

point of view

point of view

Our return is not a dream, it is an internationally recognized right.

Ignazio Cassis, Swiss Minister of Foreign Affairs, declared on Thursday 17 May 2018 that the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA) is an obstacle to peace in the Middle East as it actively hinders the integration of Palestinian refugees in their host countries.

Cassis claimed that the preservation of refugee camps, specifically in Jordan and Lebanon, sustains a “dream of returning home” for Palestinians who reside in them.” He added that the funding of UNRWA by the international community contributes to keeping the conflict alive. He stated, “For a long time UNRWA was the solution to this problem, but today it has become part of the problem. It is unrealistic that all of them [Palestinian refugees] can fulfil this dream. Yet UNRWA keeps this dream alive.”

He instead proposed the diversion of funding from UNRWA to host countries in order to foster the integration of Palestinian refugees, a policy which not only disregards the rule of law, but supports the position of the Israeli Prime Minister who called for the termination of UNRWA last month. BADIL highlights that the main obstacle to solving the Palestinian refugee question has been Israel’s denial of the right return of Palestinian refugees to their homes of origin, an ongoing policy since 1948.

International responsibility

Another key obstacle has been the failure of international community to fulfill its responsibilities towards Palestinian refugees enlisted in the numerous UN resolutions adopted since 1948. Unable to return to their homes, Palestinian refugees have been forcibly exiled in neighboring countries.

These refugees are not “dreaming” of returning home, they have a right to do so. Their right of return is specifically stated in UNGA Resolution 194 of 1948, which has been approved annually by the UN General Assembly as well as by other international bodies.

UNRWA’s services to Palestinian refugees are not sustaining the present conflict; rather, responsibility lies with the Israeli policies denying Palestinian refugees the right to return home, in contravention of international law. And as long as they remain displaced, Palestinian refugees have a right to humanitarian assistance.

Statement of André Simonazzi, Federal Council spokesperson.

“President Alain Berset spoke (Friday) with Ignazio Cassis, the federal councillor responsible for foreign affairs. The outcome of the discussion was that there is no change to Switzerland’s policy towards the Middle East, as defined in the Federal Council’s foreign policy strategy. In particular, there is no change regarding Switzerland’s support for UNRWA, a strategic partner, which plays a vital role in the region’s stability and the fight against radicalisation, as the Federal Council has made clear in a number of responses to parliamentary procedural requests. Switzerland will continue to play an active part in the reform of UNRWA, as it has done to date. As one of the main contributors to UNRWA’s budget, it is legitimate for Switzerland to be involved in reflections on the future of this organisation.”

end of infobox

UNRWA was established in 1950to provide relief to Palestinian refugees; it has never been mandated to seek solutions to the conflict. The UN Agency that was established to fulfil such duty, the United Nations Conciliation Commission for Palestine (UNCCP), has been inactive since the 1950s, leaving Palestinian refugees with no international agency mandated to seek durable solutions.

Accusing UNRWA of keeping the conflict alive is ignoring the root cause of the problem and disregarding Israel’s central role in it. The redirection of funds from UNRWA to host countries in an attempt to integrate Palestinian refugees is not a strategy aimed at improving the well-being of those refugees nor at ending the conflict, it is a move that aims to put the Palestinian refugee issue to rest.

This strategy is intricately linked to the demise of UNRWA, which serves as a reminder of the international community’s failure to find a viable solution for the world’s largest and longest standing displaced population. Palestinian refugees today comprise two thirds of the total Palestinian population, around 7.5 million, the majority of whom still live less than 100 kilometers away from their homes of origin.

Cassis’ statement that “it is unrealistic that all of them can fulfil this dream” represents both a complete disregard of the Palestinian right of return, by referring to it as a dream rather than an internationally recognized right, and also an implicit acceptance of Israel’s refusal to recognize this right.

The reason the return of Palestinian refugees to their homes of origin could be considered “unrealistic” is because Israel enjoys complete impunity for its illegal actions and bares no consequences for its continuous denial of Palestinian refugees’ right to return. It is not a matter of space, geography, or logistics, but rather politics: the unwillingness of both Israel and the international community to recognize and realize the rights of Palestinian refugees.

We conclude this letter by reminding the international community, including Switzerland, of its obligation to provide protection and seek durable solutions for Palestinian refugees. We also remind the international community that the right to reparations, including return, of Palestinian refugees is an internationally recognized right and that Israel’s denial of return is not only illegal, but fuels further displacement in light of the lack of accountability for its actions.

If Switzerland and other countries genuinely care about ending the Palestinian refugee issue and the resulting conflict in the Middle East, they should start by ensuring respect for international law, ensuring the realization of the basic rights of everyone involved, including Palestinian refugees, and putting an end to the ongoing violations of such rights.

This letter was originally published by the BADIL Resource Center for Palestinian Residency and Refugee Rights.



2 replies

  1. My suggestion to Muslim Palestine.

    Please contemplete or reflect a moment — actually your grand parents and grand parents have made big mistake who colonized the land of Jews for centuries— now Jews became a strongest tiny country in the Middle East— they want to get back their own land from Muslim Arab ( colonizer ) by force as Arab colonizer did to them thousand years ago.

    My suggestion.
    Follow our prophet Muhammad one time he immigranted to other country to avoid bloodshed on his followers-/
    It was wise indeed. So I advice Palesitine to immigrant to Arab countries— for the sake of your children and next generation.

    Do not follow a bad advice from your leaders who ask your children to be sacrificed for the sake of piece of land thst belong to God.

    All love ❤️
    I wish you a blessed and peaceful Ramadhan

    All love

    • First of all you are totally wrong to say that ‘your grand parents colonized the land of Jews. All indications are that the Palestinians in fact come from Jewish roots, converted to Islam at a later stage. Jewish historians say ‘because by converting they could avoid paying taxes’ We Muslims say because they found Islam a wonderful religion. To say that Muslim Arab colonized Palestine is falling victim to Zionist propaganda. Read ‘The Invention of the Jewish people’ by Jewish Israeli historian Shlomo Sands.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: