New York: a rabbi, an Imam and a message of inclusion at Muslim parade

At about 1 p.m. on Sunday, Diakita Amadou burst out the doors of the hotel he works at on 38th Street in Manhattan and took off. He had heard the adhan, the Muslim call to prayer, echoing through the lobby, and followed its song.

At Madison Avenue he stopped. Scores of fellow believers were prostrate in the middle of the avenue, praying before the start of the city’s Muslim Day parade. He slipped off his shoes and joined them, bowing low.

“To see the Muslims like this in the middle of the street here, that means Muslims have some consideration, that we are being given a chance,” Mr. Amadou, 45, said. “That’s New York showing us a little bit that Muslims have a right, just like other people.”

That message of inclusion was writ large at this the 32nd iteration of the parade, which for the first time had as its grand marshal a rabbi: Marc Schneier, the president of the Foundation for Ethnic Understanding, a group that works to bridge divides both religious and secular.


“This is a city of parades,” said Imam Shamsi Ali, one of the parade’s founders. “We felt we must express ourselves as an integral part of the city.” Credit Mark Abramson for The New York Times

Along the avenue, floats bearing dancers and sparkly replicas of things like the Dome of the Rock, the central mosque in Jerusalem, readied for the parade to kick off. With his grand marshal sash across his chest, Rabbi Schneier stood chatting with one of the parade’s founders, Imam Shamsi Ali, and a Hindu priest.

“This can serve as a wonderful paradigm,” said Rabbi Schneier, an activist who in February held a rally in Times Square following President Trump’s ban on travelers from several Muslim-majority countries, under the banner, “Today I am a Muslim Too.”

The parade was founded as a means for Muslim New Yorkers to assert their place in this city, said Imam Ali, the president of the Muslim Foundation of America.

“This is a city of parades,” said Imam Ali. “We felt we must express ourselves as an integral part of the city. Parade is part of the New York identity.”

Continue reading the main story


Another honorary marshal, Alaaeldin Moawad, cried during afternoon prayers before the start of the parade in Manhattan. Credit Mark Abramson for The New York Times

Over its three decades, the parade’s political resonance has been in constant change. In 2001, it was canceled after the Sept. 11 attacks; in 2002, it marched on, but the crowds were thin, Imam Ali said, as anxious past participants stayed home in a time of cresting Islamophobia.

On Sunday, amid a national climate where every group seems to be under attack, the parade transformed into something of a solidarity march.

The decision to tap Rabbi Schneier as grand marshal, Imam Ali said, came after the violence in Charlottesville, Va., where white supremacists marched this summer, shouting slogans against blacks as well as Jews, resulting in riots that left one person dead. It was decided then that this year’s parade must also be a platform.

“Anti-Semitism is not his fight alone; it is mine, too.” Imam Ali said, referring to the rabbi. “Islamophobia is not my fight alone; it is his, too. We must fight for one another.”

Continue reading the main story


Muslim officers from the New York Police Department marched in formation. At points along the parade route, spectators called out their thanks to the officers. Credit Mark Abramson for The New York Times

With an accompaniment of drums, Muslim officers from the New York Police Department marched in formation. The parade route to the Flatiron district was thinly attended, but at points spectators called out their thanks.

While there were a few protesters along the route, Imam Ali welcomed them as “Democracy in action.”

In a cluster on 38th Street, Mulhat Kahlef, 21, a home health aide from Queens, stood taking a selfie with her friends and family in their colorful hijabs, waving small American flags. The elements of shared faith between Muslims and Jews, she said, made the rabbi a perfect choice for grand marshal.

The group used to come to the parade for fun, Ms. Kahlef added, but in this year of travel bans, they came to make a statement

Just down the street, selling Bangladeshi, Yemeni, Saudi Arabian and American flags along the parade route, Al Knight, from Brooklyn, was stunned by the choice of grand marshal. “The world looks at New York, we are the capital of the world,” he said. “If other countries see that, they might become a little more pliable.”

He was just there to sell flags, and neither Muslim or Jewish, but he was deeply proud. “This is good,” he said. “This is really good.”

Categories: USA

6 replies

  1. For me it is not a right time to show a force or strength of Muslims against white supremacy. It is not wise act.

    Why did not Ahmadiyyah Muslim join the Muslim parade in New York?

  2. Somi , Ahmadiyya community has been facing persecution since 1974 and has not iterated a word nor protested. Simply because Islam teaches one to become loyal to ones country and follow the law and obey the ruler. Ahmadis all over the world do that in each country for the country that they reside in,they remain loyal and patriotic and if need be they offer the ultimate sacrifice for that country.

    • It is cool, I agree that al Quran 4:59 say that and also Bible say the same. But Islam also allow to critize the ruler wise and peacefully. USA also allow citizen to protest their Ruler peacefully, except Saudi Arabia dose not allow its citizen to protest the ruler and Clerics. Those who critize the ruler anf clerics are accused enemy and should be punished.

  3. Jew are TRAITORS using Muslims as weapons against the white Christian West. Don’t ever forget this. They all hate democracy. They all hate white people. And when they have the numbers they will kill us once the Jews get both our 2A and 1A rights taken away from us. These two groups of people are sick degenerates that need to be purged from all white homelands.

    In the name of Allah, the Gracious, the Merciful


    Love for all, Hatred for None
    This is an Ahmadi discord server open to All Faiths and discord is a great area to discuss and communicate.The Link above is of a discord server invite click it and you are invited. Also Rafiq I think you guys should promote the server!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.