Islam and Apostasy: Show Who’s Boss

Source: The Economist

A death sentence issued by a Sudanese court has stirred up controversy

THE Koran is categorical. “There is no compulsion in religion,” it says (in the 256th verse of the second sura, or chapter). In another passage of the Muslim holy book, in the tenth sura, we find God asking the Prophet Muhammad a rhetorical question: “Had your Lord so willed it, all on earth together would believe, so can you then force the people to be believers?”

The same question may be posed to the government of Sudan. Not for the first time its courts have condemned a citizen to death for apostasy, the rejection by a believer of his or her faith. In this case the supposed criminal is a 27-year-old married woman with two small children; the smaller one, a girl, was born in prison soon after her mother was sentenced to hang.

The Sudanese authorities protest that the ruling can be appealed, hint that President Omar al-Bashir may commute it, and note that the case is complex. The condemned woman, Maryam Yahya Ibrahim, was born to a Christian mother and a Muslim father and so, under Sudan’s version of Islamic law, must be a Muslim. But her father abandoned the family when she was young. She was brought up as a Christian, married a Christian and, when denounced to the authorities by a relative, refused in court to change her faith.

In practice death sentences for apostasy have rarely been imposed, especially in modern times. Sudan, however, is an exception. In 1985 it executed Mahmud Muhammad Taha, a 76-year-old human-rights activist and religious reformer. He was judged an apostate because, ironically, he preached that Islamic law as practised in Sudan was cruel, based blindly on tradition rather than the tolerant spirit of Islam.

Read further

1 reply

  1. In the Name of allah the Gracious Ever Merciful
    The Islam is such a beautiful and Natural religion that when its teachings are presented in its true perspective who could points his finger to its natural and beautiful teachings, whle apostasy law and the blasphemy laws both are un-natural and inhuman, how they could be part of Islam. That is why the Holy Quran is an open book agains apostasy and there is been no worldly punishment sogested by the Holy Quran for blasphemy. The only kind of apostasy that has been permited in Islam was when the established state has threat to its very existance, otherwise a peaceful person has every right to act according to the call of his or her conscious othervise there would be hypochracy all over the world which is useless more so it brings defame to the religion.
    Zarif Ahmad

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.