‘Ahmadis are non-Muslims,’ says Naveed Qamar, is he out of his wits?

Source: Hadi Aziz (Dec 11th, 2012) in The News Tribe. 

Islamabad: Pakistan’s Federal Minister for Defence Naveed Qamar on Tuesday said that no government employee has the authority to declare Ahmadis as Muslims.

According to the constitution of Pakistan, Ahmadis are declared as non-Muslims and they cannot use anything having resemblance to Muslim ideology.

Jang reporter Ansar Abbasi on Monday pointed out that a diplomat in a foreign country invited several Muslim Pakistanis to attend a conference organized by Ahmadis.

He indicated that the official sent invitations to Pakistani community via emails saying that the main cause of the convention was to counter the propaganda against an anti-Islam film, Innocence of Muslims. He further said that literature of Ahmadi community was also distributed among the participants of the convention.

Read More

Read a quote from Quaid-e-Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah (Founder of Pakistan)

Chief Editor’s comments:

According to Allah and His prophet, Muhammad, may peace be on him, no Muslim has the authority to call one, who believes in the Creed of Islam, as non-Muslim.

Perhaps the Minister of Defense has never taken the trouble to try to define a ‘Muslim.’  We offer him some help from the Amman Message.  Additionally, I wonder if he has learnt anything about Separation of Mosque-Church and State and if he has read his job description?

11 replies

  1. I think the Defense Minister Naveed Qamar is not in a right state of mind. He should do the job assigned to him by President Zardari. He should not talk about religion because it is not his cup of tea.
    Naveed Qamar please focus your attention towards defense of Pakistan for which you are getting paid. Leave this Issue of Muslim Non Muslim to Mullahs who are looking after this issue very well by dividing our nation into different types of Muslims.

  2. Statement of defence minister of Pakistan is very alarming for them, they are inviting
    the wrath of Allah which is already at their door.

  3. I wrote on the original website:

    All over the world anyone who recites ‘There is no God but Allah and Mohammad (peace be on him) is his prophet’ that makes one a Muslim, but not in Pakistan. In Pakistan this makes one ‘only’ an Ahmadi-(Muslim), because in Pakistan you only become a Muslim when you add ‘and I do not believe in Mirza Ghulam Ahmad of Qadian’ (remember, when you applied for an I.D. card or a passport?)

  4. There is a need of BIG correction here. one should say that no government employ has the right to declare anyone non Muslims. In fact no government in the world has the right to interfere in anyone’s belief.
    And there is not a single example of such violation of human rights in the world where a strictly personal matter as religion was taken into constitution. It is solely one’s personal matter.
    This is common sense which most Pakistanis, specially Mullahs’and Government officials very much lack in.

  5. Let the defence minister know that the founding father of pakistan had categorically stated before the members of the national assembly that religion or faith is a private affair between an individual person and his Creator, God Almighty and that state of pakistan will have nothing to do with the religion of any person.
    In all civilized societies, no one has got the right to interfere or reject the declaration of an individual regarding (1) only the son has got the right to name his father and which must be accepted by all. No one has got the right of not accepting it. (2)And about the name of my religion, it is only me and me alone who has the sole right to name my faith or religion. All others in society have to accept the the names of both, my religion as well as the name of my father. I think the defiance minister will correct his unacceptable version that no one has power to declare Ahmadis as muslims. By this logic you will be allowing others to change the name of your father or your faith is not what you say , it is what others name your religion or faith. So please do not go against the declared policy of the founding-father of pakistan. Otherwise you will make every thing look up-side-down, a very funny and strange philosophy of social life. May God have mercy on such people and their negative principles of life.

  6. Mr.Naveed Qamar, Holy Prophet(saw) said any one who says “THERE IS NONE WORTHY OF WORSHIP EXPECT ALLAH AND MUHAMMED IS HIS MESSANGER” should be counted for him as Muslim. Islam is peace and true peace come from Allah. Do you know Islam more than Holy Prophet(saw)? As people said, you better face your wordly work and If you want to know true Islam go to Ahmadi muslims to learn and accept Mirza Ghulam Ahmad(as) as promised Mesiah and Imam Mahdi because Holy Prophet(saw) said all muslim who witness his advent must take an oath from him because he is the only one that would bring faith back.

  7. What befell the originators of the constitution the stupid defense minister was referring to(the blaspheme law)- Ali Buhtto and Zia -Ul-Haq? The minister will soon be visited with similar fate.
    Is the Pakistan the only Muslim Countries we have in the World? Why are these satanic agents pretend to be holier than the holy?.

  8. Naveed & Qamar means GOOD NEWS and THE MOON does not even understand his own BLESSED NAME and UTTERING ABSOLUTE UNTRUTH CONTRADICTING THE HOLY QURAN AS EXPLAINED BY ALL AHMADI MUSLIM’S BELOVED HADHRAT MUHAMMAD,SAW,-NO ONE HAS THE RIGHT TO CALL A MUSLIM AS A NON-MUSLIM BUT ALLAH SUBHAN O TA ALA-WHAT a pity that this DEFENCE F.MINISTER is not only, is incapable of understanding the TEACHINGS OF THE QURAN E KAEEM AND THE SUNNAH OF MUHAMMAD,SAW, but also blind to NOTICE THAT HADHRAT MIRZA MASROOR AHMAD, KHALIFA TUL MASIH V, APPOINTED & ANNOINTED BY ALLAH HAS BEEN RECENTLY DELIVERing THE PEACEFUL INTERNATIONAL MESSAGE OF ISLAM PRACTISED BY HADHRAT MUHAMMAD,SAW IN THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT TO GUIDE AND HELP WORLD LEADERS TO ADOPT THE ISLAMIC TEACHINGS IN REGARD TO WORLD PEACE!!!
    THE “MOON” of PRESENT MODERN SCIENTIFIC & DIGITAL AGE HADHRAT MIRZA GHULAM AHMAD, THE PROMISED MESSIAH AND HIS KHULAFA HAVE BEEN BLESSED WITH THE PERFUM OF ISLAM SO MUCH THAT ALLAH KEEPS ON SHOWERING SUCCESS AFTER SUCCESS IN 202 COUNTRIES WHERE AHMADIYYA MUSLIMS ARE MAKING TREMENDOUS PROGRESS IN EVERY FIELD-MR N Q THE F. MINISTER SHOULD READ THE THE HOLY QURAN SURAH “AL-HAQQAH” V. 40 to 53 and RECALL THE END OF SUDANI MAHDI & IRANI MAHDI AND ALSO THE END OF BHUTTO, ZIA AND FAISAL-who opposed AHMADIYYA MUSLIMS-FACTS OF AUTHENTIC RECORDED WORLD HISTORY,INDEED!!!! According to the SEAL OF NABIYEEN,MUHAMMAD,SAW, DID PREDICT THE LIKENESS OF PIGS & MONKEYS AMONG THE SO-CALLED ULEMA OF 72 SECTS OF MUSLIMS WHO DECLARED THE AHMADIYYA MUSLIM JAMA’AT THE “ONE” OUTSIDE FROM AMONG THEM, IN FACT THEY ONLY IMPOSED THE VERDICT OF HADHRAT MUHAMMAD,SAW, AND THOSE WHO FOLLOW BLINDLY THESE PIGS & MONKEYS ARE DESTINED TO SUFFER IN FIRE.”TRUTH IS BITTER”

  9. When ever problem by moulvies is created such statements are made. From the inner core of their hearts they know Ahamdiyya is the only community which is practicising and spreading real teachings of Islam arond the globe. And this was the reason it was called to defend the respect of prophet Muhammad (saw)

  10. Naveed Qamar’s opinion is not important. He should better focus on his job of fighting Taliban. That is what he is paid to do.

  11. In the Name of Allah the Most Gracious Ever Merciful
    Either the Defense Minister of Pakistan is the biggest fool who does not understand with what fire he is playing with or infect he is the real enemy of Pakistan. His statement prove that he is extremist Mullah and being Defense Minister of Pakistan Nuclear power/ bomb in Pakistan is no more in safe and secure hands. Services of such fool and enemy should be immediately be dispensed with. Our dear country could not and would not afford any extremist in such a sensitive post.
    Zarif Ahmad

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.