Research by a local newspaper has revealed questionable practices by canton Schwyz when foreigners apply for naturalisation.
This content was published on August 28, 2023
Do you know the colour of most cows in the village of Muotathal? Can you name two animal species that live in Goldau Zoo? If you want to apply for a Swiss passport in Muotathal or Arth, this would be an advantage. You may encounter these questions during the naturalisation process.
Research by the Freier Schweizer newspaper reveals numerous animal questions and other curiosities for people applying for a Swiss citizenship in the central canton of Schwyz. Citing the freedom of information principle, the local newspaper asked all 30 Schwyz municipalities for their lists of questions that are put to aspiring new citizens.
The results have attracted the interest experts. “There are some questions that are not allowed,” says Barbara von Rütte, a lawyer and civil rights researcher at the Europa Institute of the University of Basel. “For instance, questions about the colour of the cows’ hair, for which there is no clearly correct answer, are problematic.”
The example from Arth is also revealing for von Rütte. “The research shows that this community is still asking very obscure questions.” This continues despite a Federal Supreme Court reprimand for the Schwyz municipality in 2019 for its naturalisation practice.
MoreItalian unfairly denied Swiss citizenship after 30-year residenceThis content was published on Jan 27, 2020An Italian man, who had been living in Switzerland for 30 years, was not given a fair chance to win Swiss citizenship by his local authority, the…
Back then, an Italian who had been living in Switzerland for 30 years was refused a passport because, among other things, he did not know that bears and wolves lived in the same zoo enclosure.
Such subtleties have “no place in the naturalisation process”, the court ruled. Naturalisation is “not a specialist exam” and it shouldn’t ask for “more than could reasonably be expected from an average Swiss resident in the community”.
Barbara von Rütte agrees. Anyone who meets the set requirements should be accepted as a citizen. “Naturalisation is neither a political decision nor a privilege, but an administrative act.” Lists of questions per se are not forbidden. “But they must not amount to a disguised, second knowledge test.” Federal law stipulates that candidates must complete only one test in civic knowledge.
MoreWas your grandma Swiss? You have six months left to claim Swiss citizenshipThis content was published on May 29, 2017From January 1, 2018, it will no longer be enough to have a Swiss grandmother or great-grandmother to qualify for a Swiss passport.
Several municipalities are currently revising their lists of questions. “But this has nothing to do with either the Supreme Court judgment or the newspaper report,” said Daniela Schuler, municipal clerk of the Schwyz town of Rothenthurm, which has around 2,500 residents.
There are other curious questions, which includes candidates in one community being asked if “there should be more immigration to Switzerland”. Muslims can be asked how they feel about “the fact that girls have to attend swimming lessons”.
MoreTrilingual Brit denied Swiss citizenship for not knowing origins of racletteThis content was published on Jun 5, 2018Philip Smith, who now runs a café in Zurich, was denied the red passport because he didn’t know which canton the melted cheese speciality came from.
Because some questions are “outdated”, Unteriberg will also consider revisions. Although dual citizenship is allowed in Switzerland, candidates are asked: “If you had to choose between one of the two passports, which one would it be?” Oliver Bowald, municipal clerk from Unteriberg, said: “This question is never asked because it is none of our business.”
Nevertheless, doing without the list of questions entirely is not an option for the municipality with almost 2,500 inhabitants. “If we get stuck during a naturalisation conversation, we could fall back on the list.”
How we work
Articles in this story
- Italian unfairly denied Swiss citizenship after 30-year residence
- Was your grandma Swiss? You have six months left to claim Swiss citizenship
- Trilingual Brit denied Swiss citizenship for not knowing origins of raclette
In compliance with the JTI standards