German public schools are teaching Islam to students who are not sure if they belong


Mansur Seddiqzai, 38, teaches Islam at a high school in the western German city of Dortmund. (Luisa Beck/The Washington Post).  The Muslim Times has the best collection of articles to refute Islamophobia

Source: Washington Post

By Luisa Beck, who is a reporter in The Washington Post’s Berlin bureau. Before joining The Post, she made radio stories, audio walks and podcasts for NPR,

DORTMUND, Germany — It was the second week of Islam class, and the teacher, Mansur Seddiqzai, stood in front of a roomful of Muslim teens and pointed to the sentence on the chalkboard behind him: “Islam does not belong to Germany.”

He scanned the room and asked, “Who said this?”

Hands shot up. “The AfD?” a student with a navy blue headscarf said, referring to Germany’s far-right anti-refugee party. “No,” Seddiqzai shook his head. “Seehofer,” tried another. “Yes, and who is that?” “A minister,” said a third.

Finally, someone put it all together, identifying Horst Seehofer, the head of Bavaria’s conservative Christian Social Union and Chancellor Angela Merkel’s interior minister and coalition partner, who has on multiple occasions threatened to torpedo her government over the issue of immigration.

“Yes, that’s right,” Seddiqzai said, turning to the others. “And what do you think? Is he correct?”

In a country where the debate over “who belongs?” has deeply divided Merkel’s government, fueled massive demonstrations and propelled the rise of anti-immigrant populism, these 16- and 17-year-olds confront versions of that question every day, in the headlines and in their personal lives: Do I belong, too? Can I be German and a Muslim?

Public schools in some of Germany’s most populous cities are helping such students come up with answers in a counterintuitive setting: Islam class.

The classes, taught by Muslims and intended for Muslim students, were first launched in the early 2000s and now are offered as electives in nine of Germany’s 16 states, by more than 800 public primary and secondary schools, according to the research network Mediendienst Integration. The classes include lessons on the Koran, the history of Islam, comparative religion and ethics. Often, discussions shift to the students’ identity struggles or feelings of alienation.

“When a German asks me which country I’m from, I tell them Turkey,” said Gulendam Velibasoglu, 17, who is taking Seddiqzai’s 10th-grade Islam class this year. She was born and raised in this western German city. Still, she says, “If I said ‘German,’ they wouldn’t accept the answer. They will see me as a foreigner, even though I’m a German citizen.”

Germany has the European Union’s second-largest Muslim population, after France, according to estimates by Pew Research. In 2016, 4.95 million people, or 6.1 percent of the German population, were Muslim. But less than half of those pray regularly, and even fewer regularly attend a mosque, according to the latest government surveys.

The country’s leaders have expressed an ambivalent view of Islam, at best. Seehofer’s statement that “Islam does not belong to Germany” came just months after the Islam-bashing AfD, or Alternative for Germany, entered parliament. Merkel denounced his statement and ruled out sharing power with the AfD. Nevertheless, the AfD has steadily gained support over the past two years: On Oct. 14, it scored the biggest electoral gains of any party in Bavaria, Germany’s second-most populous state.

Last year, the AfD hung campaign posters in Dortmund featuring women in burqas and the slogan “Stop Islamization.” This year’s poster bore the words ­“Islam-free schools!” under an image of five beaming, light-skinned children.

Seddiqzai, who was born to Afghan parents in the German city of Bochum, has a full beard and wears Nikes to school, said he worries about the effect on his students. “These posters tell them, ‘We don’t want you here,’ ” he said.

“They are not accepted in Germany, they are not accepted in the countries of their parents, and that produces this craving for a group to belong to,” he continued. “And then an Islamist comes to you and says, ‘Yeah, you don’t belong to anyone. Therefore just be Muslim.’ They offer them a third way.”

Seddiqzai sees it as part of his job to make his students more informed in their consumption of such appeals.

When local politicians were discussing a ban on headscarves this year, a group calling itself Reality Islam launched a social media campaign to protest the proposal and recruit students. Seddiqzai showed his students how to trace Reality’s Islam’s links to Hizb ut-Tahrir, an extremist group banned in Germany since 2003. He also encouraged them to question the group’s stance on the headscarf, which it claimed the Koran mandates for women.

“I show them the Koranic verses about the headscarf, and we discuss it and we see there is no clear rule that a woman or girl has to wear a headscarf,” he said. “Most of them think the Koran itself has no contradictions, and even that is wrong. There are many contradictions in the Koran.”

Some German politicians are pushing for an expansion of Islam classes in public schools as a way to encourage the cultural integration of Muslim students and to promote an interpretation of Islam that highlights German values.

“We need more religious education,” Kerstin Griese, a law­maker from the center-left Social Democratic Party, which is part of Merkel’s ruling coalition, wrote in an op-ed, “because it’s the only way to start a dialogue about our own traditions and values and to understand those of others.”

Such advocates generally don’t envision non-Muslim students taking these classes to gain a better appreciation of Islam. While a few German school systems offer religion classes that include multiple faiths or ethics classes that touch on religion, religion as taught in public high schools and supported by Germany’s Basic Law is generally targeted at specific denominations.

A further rationale for Islam classes is to “immunize” Muslim students from fundamentalism, as Protestant leader Heinrich Bedford-Strohm put it.

Of particular concern is radicalization that might lead to violence. Since 2013, more than 1,000 people, most of them under 30 years old, have left Germany to fight with or support the Islamic State and other terrorist organizations.

But some educators and politicians resist the notion that Islam has a place in German public schools.

“Besides the fact that we have much more important problems in schools, it can’t be true that a German bishop is promoting Islam,” Alexander Gauland, a leader of the AfD, said after Bedford-Strohm voiced his proposal.

No studies have examined the effectiveness of Islam classes in preventing radicalization, according to Harry Harun Behr, a professor of Islamic studies and pedagogy at Frankfurt’s Goethe University.

Still, he said, the classes are valuable because they show students their faith is as important as others taught in their schools and because they show Islam as a religion that is open to reflection and self-criticism.

At Seddiqzai’s school, where almost 95 percent of students are first- or second-generation immigrants, Islam class is highly popular. When he crosses the schoolyard, he can barely walk five steps without being stopped by a student wanting to tell him about grades, romances or plans for the future.

“What Mr. Seddiqzai is teaching me is not really something you learn at mosque,” said 17-year-old Yusuf Akar. “How to interact with non-Muslims who may not be sure how to interact with us. Or who are scared of us.”

But it is more than that, too. “It shows me I’m welcome here,” Akar said. “Because the school no longer demands that we distance ourselves from our religion. They accept it and even create an opportunity to learn about it. And that gives me the feeling that I’m part of this society.”


Suggested Reading

Australia senate appoints first Muslim woman amid race row

Europeans’ Attitude Towards the Muslims: The Glass is More than Half Full

Populism in Europe rooted in Islamophobia

Integrating Europe’s Muslims – Javier Solana

75% Reject Islamophobia in Australia

How Islam Taught Medieval Christian Europe Religious and Political Tolerance

Assimilating the 44 Million Muslims in Europe; A Collection of Articles

Building the Case for Loving Co-existence of All Religions in Europe

Insights to Tackle Islamophobia in Europe

Today is the Anniversary of Goethe – Was He a Muslim?

5 replies

  1. Islam via the koran is clearly against the Grundgesetz. So: as long as we have the Grundgesetz, Islam doesn’t belong to Germany.

    • Greg: Please visit an Ahmadiyya Muslim Mosque and discuss this matter. In the Ahmadiyya Muslim Community it is stated that ‘Love for your Homeland is part of your faith’, which makes members of our community more loyal citizens then the ‘original’ inhabitants.

  2. I foresee trouble ahead! How is the influx of so many people from other parts of the world with their alien cultures any different to the colonisation by Europeans of other parts of the world? Islam is expanding, which may be what the Muslims want, but why should it be acceptable to the world they have come to? And why, when they want to live in an Islamic world do they come to non–Muslims countries and to cause unrest? Why do they not remain in Muslim countries? Is it because life in Christian based countries are better, if not perfect? I know the situation in the Middle East is difficult (and I acknowledge that the West has a large part to play in this), as is life in third world countries in general, but is that reason to infiltrate other countries and change the character of those countries? This is what is happening, and toleration has its limits. The focus should be on developing those countries and also encouraging people to go back to their homelands. I feel very strongly about this. 50 years ago Muslims were a small minority and a novelty in Europe. We had friends spread around, they did not look out of place, and were mostly reasonably accepted by the natives of the land. Now there are whole areas which are exclusively Muslim, and one feels as though being in another country. And mosques are springing up in all areas, which speaks for itself. If I want to live in a Muslim country, then I would move to one, but oh, they wouldn’t accept me! And also, much of the world, such as India, China, Africa and the Middle East, threw out the European colonisers. And rightly so! It’s a strange situation. I know I have written about this before, but there seems to be no end to the problem, to which I am actually quite sympathetic, but moving to Europe is not the solution.

    • I see the situation a bit different. The vast majority of those who have arrived in Europe just want a peaceful life and schools for the children and work for their parents (or fathers at least). While they are in Europe why not let them live according to their religion? Mosque belongs to their daily life and harms no one. (usually). Most of them, sort of 98%, are not interested in sharia law and all that and are quite satisfied with the justice prevailing in the host countries. Yes, the 2 percent should leave and go to Mohammed bin Salman’s ‘moderate’ Saudi Arabia or to Pakistan / Talibanistan. And, yes, if all the foreign meddling for instance in Syria would not have taken place many of those who came to Europe would have loved to remain at home. Syria was a lovely country (as long as one did not contradict big brother Assad).

  3. Rafiq. The issue is numbers of immigrants. There is a limit to how many can be absorbed. There are just too many, particularly recently. There needs to be some control, so that we are still aware that this is Europe. And humans are tribal, who like to live amongst their own. The scene where I live, which is London, has changed considerably over the past decades, many new people have arrived, mainly from Europe, but also from Africa and the Caribbean, the Middle East, and a few others. It is quite cosmopolitan, but those people have mostly assimilated, so slowly they have become accepted. In theory there should be some control that the balance does not tip so that any area becomes too ‘black’, Asian, or anything else, creating alien ghettos (and Muslims are the most alien looking), although it’s natural for people to stick to their own type, relatives, clans, etc., especially those at the lower end of the spectrum. Educated people tend to move to other areas. While we have to accept that there is, and has always been, a natural movement of people around the globe, it is necessary to control such movement.

Leave a Reply