A Brother’s Vengeance: The Preacher Who Could Topple Erdogan

By Maximilian Popp

The greatest threat yet to Turkish Prime Minister Erdogan comes from a former ally. Muslim preacher Fethullah Gülen and his influential followers seem determined to accomplish what the recent protest movement could not: overthrowing the current regime.

Turgut Keles loved his premier. He maintained his support of Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan through early summer, when demonstrators in Istanbul were protesting the redevelopment of Gezi Park. When Erdogan held a rally for tens of thousands of supporters, Keles was in the first row.

But just half a year later, everything has changed. “Erdogan must go,” the former fan now says, adding that the prime minister has “betrayed” millions of Turks. Keles long voted in favor of Erdogan’s conservative Justice and Development Party (AKP). But his support of the party is exceeded by his admiration of Muslim preacher Fethullah Gülen, the leader of a powerful civic movement that is now at odds with Erdogan.
Keles attended a school founded by Gülen followers, and later studied at one of the movement’s universities. The organization helped him find a job, he says. Today, Keles works for a construction company in Istanbul and remains a devoted follower. “Anyone who insults Gülen, insults me,” he says.

For a long time, Gülen and Erdogan were allies. This fall, however, the prime minister announced that tutoring centers run by the Gülen movement would be shut down. Erdogan has accused the preacher’s supporters of creating a “state within a state,” and since then the two sides have been locked in a bitter power struggle. The conflict appears to confirm what many once dismissed as a conspiracy theory — that in many cases the Gülen movement controls the police and justice system.

Just before Christmas, police arrested more than 50 suspects, among them high-ranking AKP members, business owners and the sons of three ministers. They are accused of accepting bribes and involvement with illegal oil deals with Iran.

Gareth Jenkens, a Turkey expert from the Central Asia-Caucasus Institute, suspects that Gülen supporters are behind the investigations. “The movement wants to intimidate Erdogan. It is desperately trying to prevent the closure of its tutoring centers,” he says.

A former justice minister with the AKP even says that one employee of the country’s top court sought the preacher’s advice before ruling on a case.

‘Powerful Islamist Grouping’

Afraid of being watched, Keles looks into a cafe on an Istanbul side street. He’s not actually authorized to speak about the Gülen movement, which is also why he doesn’t want to use his real name. He wants to set one thing straight: It wasn’t the movement, but Erdogan, who started the current conflict, he says. “He’s behaving like a despot.”

Fethullah Gülen, who is believed to be 72, lives in exile in Pennsylvania. He fled Turkey in 1999 when the government, which was secular at the time, accused him of attempting to Islamize the country. His some 8 million supporters run schools, media companies, hospitals and an insurance company in 140 countries, including Germany. It is the “most powerful Islamist grouping” in Turkey, according to US State Department diplomatic cables made public by WikiLeaks in 2010. The network “controls major business, trade, and publishing activities, has deeply penetrated the political scene — including AKP at high levels.”

Gülen got his start as an imam in Ederne and Izmir, and soon persuaded pious businessmen to make donations. With this he financed schools, and his supporters founded student housing known as “lighthouses,” which are a fundamental part of the organization. Keles lived in one of these facilities, which often offer free accommodation in exchange for loyalty. Dropouts say the tone inside is militaristic; residents study Gülen’s writings and sermons under a provost’s supervision.

The community recruits new supporters in its schools and tutoring centers, training them as “soldiers of light.” Their task, whether they become businessmen, politicians or judges, is to spread Gülen’s conservative vision of Islam and to expand his influence.

But despite the fact that it’s a huge organization, the Gülen movement has no address and no headquarters. Fethullah Gülen alone determines its structure and path, while the cleric’s trusted “brothers” are in charge of its most important businesses. Among these is Zaman, Turkey’s highest-circulation newspaper, along with Bank Aysa, the country’s largest.

Infiltrating the Turkish Government

More than two years ago, Gülen urged his followers to infiltrate the Turkish state in a sermon that was captured on video. “You have to penetrate the arteries of the system without being noticed,” he said. You have to wait for the right moment, until you have seized the entire power of the state.” Gülen says the video has been manipulated.

When AKP assumed power in 2002, the prime minister saw an ally in the Gülen organizations. He promoted the movement by appointing members to important positions in law enforcement and the judiciary. Together, Erdogan and Gülen ousted the military, which until then had acted as guardian of the secular state.

The five-year trial against the “Ergenekon” network, the most spectacular and controversial case in the Turkish judicial system’s recent history, has led to the arrest of generals, but also hundreds of politicians, lawyers and journalists, for their involvement in an alleged coup attempt. Crimes could be proven for individual defendants. Often, however, the allegations turned out to be fabricated. Critics say that, with Erdogan’s permission, the Gülen movement manipulated the trial to eliminate political rivals in the government and civil society. The prime minister’s chief adviser admitted two weeks ago that forces within the judiciary conspired at the time against the military. The general staff now wants to bring the case back to court.

A high-ranking former party member asserts that numerous state officials acted on the orders of the Gülen brothers: “They were our students. We trained them and supported them. When these grateful children take office, they continue to serve Gülen.”

Critical journalists were also persecuted. The reporter Nedim Sener, for instance, reported on the machinations of the Gülen community, as did his colleague Ahmet Sik. In March 2011, the two were arrested. They were not released until the following year.

‘They Want Influence and Money’

Sener says he doesn’t doubt the seriousness of the corruption allegations — but the motives of the investigators has to be questioned. These are hardly neutral jurists at work, but rather Gülen followers. “The community is not governed by rule of law and democracy,” says Sener. “They want influence and money.”

Because it’s not just about ideology; it’s also about wealth. By opening schools abroad, the Gülen movement has developed new markets for Turkish businesses. The Calic Group, for instance, which is run by Erdogan’s son-in-law, benefited from the group’s connections to the former Turkmen dictator Saparmurat Niyazov.

But the alliance between Erdogan and Gülen began to crumble after the parliamentary elections of 2011. Erdogan said the movement could no longer be relied on. Gülen’s followers, for their part, were disturbed by the prime minister’s increasingly authoritarian governing style. “Erdogan became a burden for us,” says Keles.

Among other things, the two camps are at odds over how to deal with the Kurds. Turkish intelligence chief Hakan Fidan led secret peace negotiations on the behalf of the prime minister with the Kurdish separatist Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK). Gülen, however, called on the Turkish military in a video message to attack Kurdish separatists: “Locate them, surround them, smash their units, let fire rain down on their houses, cover their wailing with still more cries of pain,” he said.

The Conflict Escalates

In February 2012 state prosecutors attempted to apprehend Erdogan’s intelligence chief. The prime minister prevented Fidan’s arrest — and transferred police powers to intelligence. The media attacked Erdogan’s actions with the same vehemence they once reserved for the opposition. In summer 2013 Gülen criticized Erdogan for his brutal handling of the Gezi protesters.

But only after Erdogan threatened to close the tutoring centers did the conflict escalate. Lawmaker Hakan Sukur, a former soccer player and national hero, announced his resignation from the AKP: “As a supporter of the movement, I take the hostilities against Gülen personally,” he said. Afterward, the daily newspaper Zaman called him a “hero with a lion’s heart” and interpreted his resignation as a “final warning.”
The corruption scandal shook the country just a day later. The prime minister is still trying to dismiss the allegations as conspiracy, speaking of a “second war of independence.” He announced he would take action against Gülen’s supporters. More than 500 police officers have already been transferred. Erdogan is expected to present a list with the names of 2,000 more alleged Gülen followers within the state apparatus.

Gülen supporter Keles says the movement is prepared to fight to the “bitter end.” Ilhan Cihaner, the opposition politician and Gülen opponent, expects further revelations in the coming weeks. He says the group possesses enough compromising documents to topple Erdogan: “The conflict is far from over.”


Categories: Asia, Turkey

2 replies

  1. The contributions of Nursi’s Nurcu and Gulen’s Hizmet movements in Turkey, successfully over the decades, have created a new civil society (like Madani civil Society of the Prophet S.A.W.) and a golden generation of Turkish youth in millions by now. Beginning with the teachings of Bedi-uz zaman Nursi ( 1877-1960) and practically furthered by Fethullah Gulen ( born 1941-), two of these enlightened public Islamic intellectuals/scholars accomplished all this without involving their social and civic movements directly into the politics. Political parties are to best serve the civil society in any democratic system or governance to genuinely succeed. In Turkey as an example, the new political party (AK Party formed in 2001) and its prime minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan for the last 12 years (3 successive terms) with the most successful Turkish government (in a century) have been supported by the strong civic society (new Madani civil society in Turkey) and jointly they (political party and the civil society) have very successfully overcome the old guard (deep militaristic Turkish state), the laic hardcore (secular Kemalist) establishment and even Islamism ( political radical Islam).

    Erdogan having been so successful in the last decade, in my view, started to become authoritarian when the new Turkish civil society remains strong and justly watchful over his party and the creeping corruption that began to show up during this last and 3rd term. Thus there is now a rift between Erdogan and the civil society (hence the above article by SPIEGEL.DE) and civil society is bound to overcome this. The civil society, as it should, presently remains instrumental helping weed out all the politicians lately being caught in corruption charges in Turkey.

    Pakistan has had a desperate needed to transform its own civil society into Madani like society. The Pakistani religious scholarship engaged day and night in theological discourses and textual intricacies that now seems unfortunately to have lost ground in terms of contributing and creating the emerging Madani like civil society. In the current religious landscape, the Ahmadiyya Jamaat as one of the few sane and rational voices in my view, and even Javed Ahmad Ghamidi thought seem to have lost their original direction within Pakistan and have thus in exile ventured to continue their noblest true Islamic mission of peace, love and compassion for the masses and the humanity.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s