India: A Woman Can Lead Friday Prayers, It’s Not against Tenets of Islam

By Syeda Hameed

February 01, 2018

I was a member of the National Commission of Women in 1998 when I met Daud Sharifa, who was building a mosque for women at Puddokotai, Tamil Nadu, since women were denied entry into mosques there.

Last week, I read reports that a woman in Mallapuram district led the Friday prayers, which was attended by 50 people.

Speaking to reporters, the woman, K Jamitha, said Islam does not forbid women to be imams, it only refers to Momins (faithful) men and women and so what she did was in keeping with the spirit of Islam.

However, a recent piece — Aurat ki Imamat — published in the Urdu media has listed many reasons why a woman leading the prayer is against tenets of Islam.

Much of the article is a deliberate misreading of the teachings and spirit of the religion. This is nothing new. Ever since the advent of Islam, misreading and misrepresentation have been a patriarchal campaign, which flies in the face of the words of Allah, the sayings of the prophet and his exemplary life.

One of the main arguments against women imams and Qazis has been that these women do not have a proper understanding of the Quran. The word used for women by most Muslim clerics is “Naqesul Aql, meaning “deficient mind”.

Islam has unflinching regard and respect for women. The Quran, the Hadith, and the Sunnah are imbued with raising the status of women in a brutal, misogynist, patriarchal Arab society. Its most revolutionary act in a society that buried its girl children at birth was to give women property rights.

At a time when women were inferior to domestic animals and chattel, Islam enjoined women to become ‘Shahid’ (witnesses) in legal disputes.

The Quran says two women are equal one man, but that was only to ‘begin with’. Unfortunately, 1,436 years later our community is still stuck in that ancient time warp; what Islam brought to the Arab world was light years ahead of prevalent social practice. What progress have we made since the beginning of that Hijri calendar and Quran’s revolutionary injunctions?

Allama Iqbal, the great poet, was referring to Muslims when he wrote:

Na Samjhoge To Mit Jaoge Ai Hindustan Walo/ Tumhari Daastaan Tak Bhi Na Hogi Daastanon Mein

(If you don’t understand, you will vanish, citizens of India/Even your story will not remain in the stories)

The first word of Quran is ‘read’. That one word is the key to moving on, to explore new frontiers of understanding. Surah Al Baqr of the Quran refers to Summun, Bukmun, Umiyun, (deaf, dumb and blind) those who will not heed the words of Allah and will apply their own Kufr (heresy) to create mischief (Fasad) in the world.

Muslim men have rarely projected the gendered face of Islam. The more they say that women are inferior, the more the world turns away from a faith, which came as Rahmat ul Alameen (mercy to humankind) to the world and taught the lesson of Mussawaat(equality) to those who listened.



12 replies

  1. Are you a prophet of the modern Islam?

    If not which modern prophet do you follow?

    Do you have a modern scripture or textbook of Islam?

    Please do not avoid answers by referring me to your obsolete web site.

    • @ Muhammad Ahmad:
      Even though I answer your question you will not be sutisfied, you are in anger, do not accept different interpretation of Islam. Progressive Muslim want to renew the old interpretation of Islam in order we can see Islam us a religion of peace, and mercy again.

      Editor: repetitions deleted.

  2. There are female Jewish rabbis and Protestant Priests/vicars. There is no logical reason why women can’t become religious leaders, even in Islam, as well as Catholicism. Time for progress.

    • Unfortunately most Arab clerics still be proud to follow their ancestors back to 1430 years ago where women were treated as slave, unclean.
      Whereas other verses say that male and female are equal at front of law. There is no discrimination base on gender and race.

      Ahmafiyyah still follow Arab culture or tradition whereas Ahmadiyyah live in modern society.


      • Somi always speaks negatively. Do you recall the article that it was a lady who founded the oldest University in Morocco? look it up. And … as I told you, when I travelled around the world I found that in Muslim countries it was more likely that a house / apartment was owned by a lady then in the modern Western countries. In Pakistan and in Jordan I found that we rented houses from ladies. Yes, the husband might have shown us the house, but when it was time to make a rental contract he said ‘ you now have to speak to my wife, it is her house ‘.

  3. Rafiq, yes I still remember what you said.
    But in this case do you support women to be Imam in your mosque or other mosque— or you reject women to be Imam in mix prayers ( male and female) like in India.
    Just to make clear where is Ahmadiyyah’s position.


    • Ahmadis follow the advice of the Khalifa. There is no such advice so far. Me? I am a weak male chauvenist. I would be distracted from prayer when a lady is in front of me, honestly speaking …

      • Ok Rafiq, I like you, you are a honest person.
        You better ask your Khalifa, it is nice to know it,
        where Ahmadiyyah position in that issue.
        God bless you Rafiq

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.