Pakistan was meant for all sects

I love Secularism

The Muslim Times has the best collection to promote secularism in every country and overcome sectarian divide  among the Muslims

Source: The Express Tribune

By Talat Masood, who is a retired lieutenant general of the Pakistan Army and a former federal secretary. He has also served as chairman of the Pakistan Ordnance Factories Board

Seventy years is more than a lifespan for an average Pakistani but for a nation it may be a period of its infancy. But we cannot hide behind this cover for we are not a people who did not have a history, rich civilisation or a past. Moreover, we have most recent examples of China, Singapore and Southeast Asian nations led by dedicated leaders that were able to transform their countries.

In contrast, it does not reflect well on us that in 70 years we have not even been able to develop a consensus on the raison d’être for seeking a separate homeland. Many amongst us are still unclear as to what were the motives and challenges that gave rise to the very concept of its creation? We are still interpreting the basis of the two-nation theory. The religious political parties would like us to believe that religion is the conceptual basis of Pakistan. And based on that Pakistan should be a theocratic state grounded in the orthodox principles of Islam. Opposed to that are those who argue that Jinnah used the two-nation theory merely to bargain for a separate homeland and to protect the rights of Muslims who were a substantial minority in India. Jinnah was also more emphatic on the cultural rather than the religious differences. With nearly 96% of the population being Muslim, Pakistan does not need the crutch of religion. Experience has shown that differences among the various Muslim sects tend to make the society more divisive. When religion is exploited for political purposes instead of being a binding force it becomes discordant. Furthermore, it is a misguided belief that a secular state is an irreligious state. Secularism allows greater option and flexibility for people to pursue their faith in accordance with their wishes and not to be straitjacketed by the state or any specific denomination.

Pakistan was meant for all sects be it Sunni, Shia, Barelvi or Deobandi and it was never supposed to be a divisive state. At the time of partition, there was considerable harmony among various denominations of religious belief and it is sad that now it is the opposite. These differences were deliberately accentuated for political gains. Surely, the sectarian malaise will not go away unless our leaders and religious parties focus on being more inclusive and democratic.

Jinnah’s concept to create Pakistan was to protect the minority rights of Muslims so that both Indians and Pakistanis could live in peace. That dream not only remains unfulfilled but we also are in a worse situation where both countries treat each other as enemies. The questions we need to address at 70 are whether the two countries are destined forever to live in a state of perpetual hatred?

This sad state of affairs is sapping the energy of the nation and has to be rectified. For Pakistan, hostility with India is even more costly. With Prime Minister Modi in India and a weak civilian government in Pakistan to expect a bold initiative being taken to normalise relations would be difficult. Unfortunately the media’s role in promoting discord between the two nations has been significant.

On the domestic side, our politics cannot continue the way it is being practised. Difference of opinion and divergence in policies is integral to democratic norms. But the venomous and personalised politics that Pakistani leaders are pursuing needs to be strongly rejected. Their behaviour has lowered the image of politicians in the eyes of the public.

secularism 6.jpg

Moreover, political parties need to take their responsibility of empowering parliament seriously. Their lack of interest in discussing national issues and framing laws compatible with running a functional state have further tilted power in favour of the judiciary and military.

Pakistan needs to seriously reassess its economic policies. Heavy reliance on foreign assistance and pathetic tax collection have made our economy highly vulnerable despite the current modest 5.3% growth in GDP.

The education system in general and that of madrassas has to conform to the requirements of modern times. Those few madrassas that are spreading hatred and preaching violence have to be banned. Fear of backlash has kept the government vacillating while dealing with this phenomenon.

Our state education system is also not keeping pace with the requirements of teaching modern science and technology subjects. This weakness could have serious consequences for the national economy and future growth prospects. We are already witnessing a sharp decline in exports and our manpower acceptability in foreign countries is becoming difficult. No country can keep pace with the modern world if a significant proportion of its population is illiterate. It also affects every major sphere of national activity. The quality of politics, economy and cultural pursuits of a nation are in one way or the other related to the level of education of its people.

It is the focus on education and largely promotion of science and technology that propelled developing nations like South Korea, China and Malaysia to progress after their independence. India too is surging ahead in education and many Indians are heading the world’s top multinationals like Google and Microsoft.

Despite many odds and notwithstanding our weaknesses, we can justifiably take pride in what we have achieved in the last 70 years, especially considering from where our journey started. We remain a highly resilient nation that has withstood foreign pressures and achieved stability and relative peace in a volatile region. We can be proud of having one of the finest professional armies that guarantees the integrity of our borders and excels in counter-insurgency operations. We are the only nuclear power among the Muslim world. More significantly, despite all its weaknesses we are one of the few democratic countries among the Muslim countries. Our cricketers bring laurels and make us look tall. We fall but we rise but we need to do a lot more in the next 70 years.


8 replies

  1. I agree. Secularism and democracy are the only way. There is no place for theocracies or nationalism. Religion should be a private matter. People should be free to believe whatever they want, so long as it does not affect others.

  2. It is great analysis and good advises to those who rule the country. Author himself was part of military top brass as such can view the situation more analytically. When and where the nation went wrong. Diagnosing the problem, recommending practicable solutions with strong will to implement are required. One can say until Ayyub things were looking good. Thereafter downward journey started. Both military and civil elite are responsible for it. Leaving aside who ruled the country, India is not that good example of developing nation. Specially how minorities are being dealt there under current regime in spite of the fact military brass never ruled that country. So ultimate conclusion, it is the type of leadership which matters not from which segment of society comes the leader.
    Another important aspect is the overall moral and ethical standard of the whole nation. It is said the nation gets the leader according to its moral and ethical standards. See where the whole nation is standing from moral and ethical point view. Raising of moral and ethical standard is not always the responsibility of rulers. All societal leadership shares this responsibility. Today where this societal leadership stands in Pakistan. At the most lowest level. With communication development, TV has entered in the houses of whole nation. How this powerful societal tool is playing its role is total catastrophe. The way current scenario is being portrayed and discussed speaks of deplorable national moral and ethical standards. Non has dared to take any step to correct the situation.
    So analysis remain good to the extent of analysis and look charming on the piece of papers. The most difficult task is to get these things implemented. Currently no light is in vision at the end of tunnel. May be God Almighty some times shower His Mercy and some visionary and revolutionary leader is blessed to Pakistani Nation.

  3. “Pakistan was meant for all sects”.True but today there is a whole new story.

    This is not majority opinion of Pakistanis today. This is the reality of the time. We got to accept this reality, even though we cordially disagree.

    Solution for an Ahmadi Muslims:

    1- Prayers

    2- Do not break the law of the land

    3- Express opinion without breaking the law of land, if possible

    4- when life becomes impossible, hijrat is the sunnah of Prophet of Islam.

    Disclaimer: Everybody has right to free thinking and opinionلاَ إِكْرَاهَ فِي الدِّينِ I am expressing purely my personal opinion. I have no intention to offend anybody.

  4. I love secularism, where freedom of religion or no religion is protectedلاَ إِكْرَاهَ فِي الدِّينِ

    • @ Khalid… woow I have a good friend here, we have the same thought such as:
      1. Muslims have to obey the laws of the land
      2. If not agree, hijjarah other country
      3. I love secularism, where freedom of religion and not religion is protected.
      4. Polygamy is the ancient Islamic law is not relevant anymore in the west countries.
      5. Burqa and Nigab are also the ancient Islamic law are not relevant in the Westren society, people are afraid of terrorist.
      If Muslims want to show Islam is religion of peace , pls obey the law of the land.
      All love

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s