The Russians are coming… to Israel and Palestine


Russia recently announced that it has decided to go where angels fear to tread: into the whirlpool of negotiations between Palestine and Israel.

Long a preserve of the Americans and the French, the attempt to bring peace between the two and to make a final settlement on boundaries has frustrated them for decades.

Can Russia do better?

Russia comes on the scene at a time when the script is perhaps about to be rewritten in a radical way. 

After decades of negotiating around the premise that the only solution was a two-state arrangement with an independent Jewish state and an independent Palestinian state existing cheek by jowl, opinion in Palestine is shifting.

The talk now, especially among younger people, like businessman Tareq Abbas, the son of President of Palestine Mahmoud Abbas, is quite different from that of their parents.

They are saying that Palestinians should give up pursuing what the Israelis will never concede and should stop the endless, unproductive effort to negotiate a two-state solution.

Instead, they should accept that Israel has the whip hand over both Israel and Palestine, in both the parts it occupies and the parts it allows the Palestinians to govern themselves, the rest of the West Bank and Gaza.

So the focus of the negotiations should be changed to concentrate on demanding civil rights within Israel — a greater Israel containing Jews, Muslims and Christians.

What the Palestinians need are full citizenship and civil rights, not least the vote, in one unified state.

Three years ago, a poll by the Palestinian Centre for Policy and Survey Research found that 65 per cent of Palestinians over the age of 50 still preferred the two-state solution, compared to 48 per cent of those between 18 and 28.

The mood is changing.

The process of a change of focus is well under way, but is rarely commented on by outsiders. 

I doubt that more than 1,000 Russians are aware of it.

Since 1966, when martial law was lifted in Israel, the situation of the Arab citizens within Israel has improved greatly.

In 1960, only 70 Arab students were studying at Israeli universities. Today, there are more than 20,000, of whom two-thirds are women. 

Around 10,000 Arab Israelis are studying abroad.

There is now a growing Arab middle class, and in the last election, the Arab parties standing as a unified group became the third place winner of seats in the Knesset (parliament).

So why not build on that?

According to Professor As’ad Ghanem of the University of Haifa, 66 of the 112 towns in Israel with more than 5,000 residents have virtually all-Arab populations.

Thanks to high birth rates and a young population, half of Israel’s Arab citizens are under 20, whereas only 30 per cent of Jewish Israelis are.

Some observers, including US Secretary of State John Kerry, predict that before long, Israel with become an apartheid state, with a minority population of Jews ruling over a majority Arab population.

Israel Premier Benjamin Netanyahu has managed to dominate Israel’s internal debate among Jewish voters in a way that has not been done by a leader since David Ben-Gurion.

For public consumption, he talks of his willingness to negotiate the two-state solution. In practice, he cleverly steers all negotiations away from such a deal.

A one-state push by a new Palestinian leadership could cause him grave difficulties, not easy even for him to surmount.

No longer could he play the security card that gives political and military spine to his conviction. 

In a unitary state, there would be no military threat to counter, either from West Bank Palestinians or the inhabitants of Gaza or from the armies of Arab neighbours.

Netanyahu would find himself being outmanoeuvred in a unitary state. The Arab parties’ voting strength inside Israel would shoot up.

If they could stay more unified than the disparate Jewish parties, they would emerge as one of the two strongest parties. They would be strong enough to broker more liberal coalitions.

Ironically, if the Palestinians do decide to make a unitary state their objective, they might well end up with a two-state solution as Netanyahu and the Jewish voters run to back such a deal for fear of this alternative.

Thus, for Palestinians to focus on a one-state solution is a win-win tactic.

There is only a slim chance that a campaign for a unitary state would succeed (although in South Africa it did succeed). If it does, all well and good. If the campaign is bought off by a two-state offer from Israel, even better.

It is into this fast-moving whirlpool of new ideas that the Russians step.

Unlike the Americans and the French, they have no baggage. 

It is a good time for a new interlocutor to arrive on the scene. We should all wish it luck.


3 replies

  1. “The Russians are coming… to Israel and Palestine” @Putin: Christains were/are brought up to wipe the jews backsides, they await another christianised idiot,. (they have been caught six times you fool: Auschwitz).

Leave a Reply