General Musharaf and Pakistan

Ex President Pervez Musharaf

Ex. President Pervez Musharaf

By Munir Varraich, Sweden

Let us not forget that it was a secular minded soldier President who took a bold decision after 9/11 and tried to put the Pakistani Mindset on the right track, away from the extremism, which had been introduced by Zia ul Haq 11 years rule.

Sometime ago,  Former President of Pakistan, General Pervez Musharaf had explained as to why he took that historical decision – to support the US in the war against terrorism. In retrospect there could be many opinions by the “strategists” and “analysts” whether the “decision” was good or bad for Pakistan, as a sovereign state.

The fact remains that a “bold decision” was taken by the leader of Pakistan at that historical juncture.

It is important to remember that at the turn of 14th century Hijra (1979) the wheel of destiny started moving in a direction, which brought to the forefront Pakistan’s role in 15th century Hijra and later in the 21st century AD.

A semblance of a sort to the events in the earlier history of Muslims, when they fought the “Battle of Badr” and that is mentioned in Sura “Rum”. Romans (Believers) defeated the Persians (non-Believers) at the international plane, and the Muslims defeated the Quraish at the local plane. Both the Muslims and the Romans celebrated their victory. In our times modern day Romans (Christian West) and Pakistan (Islamic nuclear power and considered to be the leader of the Muslim World) joined hands to defeat Persians (USSR) in a “land nearby” (Afghanistan). Both the Christian West (Believers till that point) and the Muslim World (Believers till that point) celebrated the defeat of USSR (an atheist power).

The weapons used in both confrontations – by the Muslims in the Battle of Badr and by the Romans (Christians) in the battle against the Persians – was the “human being charged with the spirit of Jihad-e-Qataal. Historians like Gibbons term those battles and wars as “religious wars”.

Subscribe now to receive daily email updates from TheMuslimTimes.Org

Subscribe now to receive daily email updates from TheMuslimTimes.Org

In the Afghan War of 1979-1989, the “weapon” used by the US was “money”, “latest technology” and “powerful media”. The “weapon” used by the Muslim World was still the same as was used in the earlier times – “human being charged with the spirit of Jihad”. The word “Jihad” and its “outdated interpretation” by reputed scholars of the Muslims, became the reason, why a local Afghan war (as far as the US was concerned), became a religious war for the Muslim World.

Since modern day “Romans” did not brand that war as “Crusades” it is very obvious that the mistake of branding the Afghan war as “Jihad” fall squarely on the Muslims, especially all those religious leaders and scholars, who had not updated the interpretation of “Jihad”, in modern times but had branded any other interpretation of “Jihad” as heretic. In other words they had ignored the “concept of evolution” of human beings, which has been mentioned very clearly, again and again in their Holy Book – The Quran.

As far as the US was concerned, the defeat of the USSR was part of their Grand Strategy and they achieved their strategic goal – the defeat of their rival super power USSR and all that went with it. As far as the Muslim World was concerned, they were blinded by the wrong interpretation of “Jihad” and delved deeper into that pit for the next decade – 1989 to 1999. That pushed the Muslim Mindset away from the “evolutionary process”.

A generation was lost, till the turn of the century, when the logical result of the wrong interpretation of “Jihad” hit the Twin Towers on 9/11.

All that time the Muslim Leadership, religious as well as political had kept pampering the “Jihadi mentality” and did not dare to take the main culprits to task.

On 12th October 1999, another historical event took place in that very place – Pakistan – where the monster of “Jihad” was created by the Muslims themselves. A “democratic process” was interrupted by military take over, headed by General Musharaf, on whose shoulders history put the load of taking bold and tough decisions.

Apparently, General Musharaf had toppled a government which was “democratic” in the usual sense of the word. However, the period from 1989-1999 – those democratic governments had not taken any measures to redefine the interpretation of “Jihad”, neither to Pakistanis nor to the Muslim World. Instead, both the main political parties shied away from confronting the religious leadership.

Even after General Musharaf took over, there was no effort to confront the religious leadership on that issue. The “wake up” call came on 9/11, when US openly challenged the interpretation of “Jihad”, not only in Pakistan, but also in the rest of the Muslim World.

I shall get back to the Quran again to understand how the earlier Romans behaved towards the Muslims of Medina after the defeat of Persians. And in that light try to understand if the fateful “decision” taken by General Musharaf was in line with the “process of evolution” or against it.

History is a witness that at the Battle of Khandaq, The Prophet of Islam was shown the “Kangans or bracelets of Romans and the Persians being presented to Omar”. Later events show that the Muslims defeated the Persians first. The weapons and strategy to defeat the Persians was the same “human being charged with the spirit of Jihad”. Persia was defeated both materially and ideologically and has remained Muslim till today.

However, when the earlier Muslims had to face the Romans, the opponent also used a similar weaponry as the Muslims – “human being charged with the spirit of Jihad”. In that confrontation a belief system which acknowledged “the concept of evolution of the human being” was bound to be victorious. “the Bible” being an older concept could not stand up to the “updated” teaching – “the Quran”.

Fast forward to the 21st century event of 9/11. General Musharaf took a decision to “dump” the wrong interpretation of “Jihad” and all that goes with it. At the international plane he was supported by the sole super power – the US. Of course, once again the Grand Strategy of the US was at play. However, The Grand Strategy of Pakistan at that juncture of history, dictated that “Jihad-e-Qatal” in all its forms had to be defeated first. Only after that the next phase of Pakistan’s Grand Strategy could be implemented.

Events after 9/11 have proven that Musharaf’s decision to support “War on Terror” was in effect in Pakistan’s and Muslim World’s interests. The only interpretation of “Jihad” by one and all – the scholars and the religious leaders, strategists and analysts – was “Jihad of the Pen” and any individual or a government saying otherwise, had no place in the civilized world.

The next step of interaction with modern day Romans will have to be at a higher plane – between “the Bible” and “the Quran” by modern day “Muslims of Badr” and not the modern day “Quraish” of Makkah. The old weaponry “human being charged with the spirit of Jihad-e-Qatal” is outdated. The new weaponry is “Jihad by the Pen” which harmonizes with and flows along the “evolution of the human being” and not against it.

It is one thing, to just say “Jihad by the Pen”, but quite another thing to practice and implement this at the national level. As such, it would only be fair to see, what General Musharaf did during his 1999-2008 tenure, to implement “Jihad by the Pen”.

It is up to the leadership, military or otherwise, and the people of Pakistan, to implement the “Jihad by the Pen”, in every walk of life, first and foremost. Only that mindset will be able to identify from where did this phrase “Jihad by the Pen” originated and when. Also, why that voice was opposed tooth and nail and silenced  by whom.

All this and much more will gradually come to light for every thinking mind.

Categories: Asia, Opinion, Pakistan

Tagged as:

6 replies

  1. Quite true. Think of the affect of victory in Afghanistan against Russia, it was all wasted. Mulla Umar jihadists had 95% of Afghanistan under their control. But where are they now! That was all due to bad leadership.
    Similarly for the Khomaini doctrine in Iran, they had the country. But their leader (Imam) taught the doctrine of confrontation by indulging in politics, by saying “America Shaitan number one. Russia Shaitan number two…”

    Instead of being thankful to Allah for the victories and turning to Him for forgiveness, and turning to peacefl Jihad by the pen, they continued on the path of Qital (war). They lost what they had.

    The fault of Gen. Musharaf is stated that he violated the constitution of Pakistan. No doubt it was a grave sin. But what constitution? A charter which had been amended many times with bad amendments. It was no more any suitable, legal document. It was (and is) unfair charter, denying human rights.
    The politicians were at fault, trying to rule the country (Pakistan) with that bad document.
    The fourth Khalifah of the Promised Messiah a.s. i.e. Hazrat Mirza Tahir Ahmad had rightly spoken that the constitution is no good. It cannot go along with Pakistan. Either the constitution will survive or the country, but not both. What he meant was that it was high time that the constitution was amended to uphold human values.

    Instead of amending the constitution in a good way, the law makers have made it worse by adding new clauses of death for blasphemy etc…
    Gen. Musharaf may be guilty. But the politicians (law makers) are more guilty of crimes against humanity. They should be charged too. The ruling parties are supporting the terrorists. How bad!

  2. In the context of your argument, could you explain why Musharraf hid Osama bin Laden in Abbotabad? Also, he got some $20B in ten years from the US for help in the fight against terror, and spent $15B to build up nuclear arsenal, so that about three years ago, Pakistan claimed “nuclear parity” with India. How many schools and hospitals could be built with $15B?

  3. Assalamu Alaikum Sir,
    I am a Computer Operator Of Multi-Sectoral Programme on Violence Against Women, Ministry of Women and Children Affairs, Bangladesh. My Salary is Only-125$ Per Month. I have some loan about-2,000$. I can not pay my loan to bear my family expense.

    So, please Sir, help me from Your Zakat fund to pay my loan as soon as possible.

    Yours Faithfully
    Helpless Muslim Brother
    Md. Yousuf Ali
    +8801197166810

    Present Address :
    One-Stop Crisis Cell (OCC)
    Upazila Health Complex.
    Shibganj,Chapainawabgang.
    MSPVAW.

    Permanent Address :
    Vill. Tongpara
    PO. Amnura (6303)
    PS. Chapai Nawabganj sadar
    Dist. Chapai Nawabganj

    BANK NAME: Islami Bank Bangladesh Limited
    BANK ADDRESS:
    Godagari Road, Chapai Nawabganj, Bangladesh.
    Phone: (0781) 55348, 61138
    Mobile: +8801711438342
    Fax: (0781) 61138
    Email: cnganj@islamibankbd.com

    MY ACCOUNT NUMBER: 20501320202802511
    MY ACCOUNT TITLE/NAME: MD. YOUSUF ALI
    BRANCH SWIFT CODE: IBBLBDDH132

  4. Dear Sir,

    Most humbly, I disagree with you on all accounts about Pervez Musharraf.

    Musharraf was a mediocre soldier of average intelligence, even though of a good heart. The former is amply exhibited by the fact that he is unable to speak any language fluently; Urdu or English, and was a poor speaker, despite public speaking being one of the key features of training in the army.

    Let’s look at some of his known achievements prior to usurping power; he refused to obey the command of the elected government to present a guard of honor to the Indian PM, who was on a good will visit to Pakistan. He derailed the Indo-Pak peace process by orchestrating the Kargil fiasco. If he had his way, he would have gone to all out war with India without knowing all his cards. He disowned his own soldiers at the war front. His military supported all the jihadi apparatus all over the country and the civil government was more a hostage to these terrorists. He usurped power through deceit and violating the oath he had taken. As a President, he mistreated the elected PM. It was not his superior ideals or a change of heart but the threat by the super power that they would “bomb Pakistan to stone age” that made him catapult his stance on jihadi elements. He ruled the country with the help of violent elements; the mulla and the MQM, and corrupt and discredited politicians. He bombed his own villages and towns in Baluchistan and NWFP. The army committed some of the worst atrocities under him on it’s own people. He repeatedly lied about his own retirement. He sacked the judiciary, strong armed the public and created havoc all over the country. The list goes on.

    I am no sage, but people like me knew the moment he stepped into the political arena, that he would leave the country destitute and worse off and the political process would start all over again, as it did. This would happen any time a COAS marches into the presidency, no matter how smart he may be. Talking to some friends, it seems that we learn from history that we do NOT learn from history as they are now banking on the next chief… What a shame.

    Ahmed.

  5. Dear Ahmad, has the country got better since the departure of Musharraf? No it has not, so what does it prove. That all the Pakistani politician are corrupt and are there to line up their pockets and could not care less about the masses. Only Allah can save this country from these corrupt politicians and ignorant mullahs, provided they follow the teachings of true Islam.
    Zafar

  6. “Jihad of the Pen”

    Wow! so you have discovered a pen that can annihilate nuclear warheads? eureka! let me know if you have a franchise in monkeyland (that’s where I live), I’d love to buy one. and hey what’s the price? …

Leave a Reply