The Supreme Court and Religious Favoritism

US Supreme Court

US Supreme Court Washington, DC, USA symbolizes justice, due process and more than 200 years of constitutional debates.  This case is her test for secularism, would the court stand on justice or yield to populism.  The Muslim Times is supporting secularism in every country of the world

Source: The New York Times

By The Editorial Board. The editorial board represents the opinions of the board, its editor and the publisher. It is separate from the newsroom and the Op-Ed section.

The case of a 40-foot cross in Maryland offers the justices a chance to clarify the constitutionality of religious displays.

On Wednesday, the Supreme Court once again took on a question that has long confounded it: What qualifies as an impermissible establishment of religion under the Constitution?

The court has over the years sent mixed signals about when the government may be playing favorites with a particular faith. For instance, in its ruling last year upholding President Trump’s executive order imposing an entry ban on people from several Muslim-majority countries, the Supreme Court insisted, in a 5-to-4 vote, that the restrictions were “facially neutral toward religion,” ignoring the president’s long history of antipathy toward Islam and its adherents. And weeks earlier, the justices ruled, in a narrow decision, for a Christian baker who had claimed mistreatment by Colorado’s civil rights commission, which penalized him for denying service to a gay couple.

secularism in USA

This week’s hearing, in American Legion v. American Humanist Association, involved a 40-foot cross in Bladensburg, Md., that was erected 93 years ago to honor fallen World War I soldiers. The question before the court: Is Maryland in violation of the First Amendment because the memorial is on public property and maintained with public funds?

Over the years, the justices have tried to come up with rules to assess all kinds of religious emblems and practices carrying the government’s imprimatur — sectarian prayers in legislative sessions, war memorials, Ten Commandments and Christmas displays, and mottos on seals or currency.

Read further

Suggested reading

Thomas Jefferson and Islam as an American Religion

Today is the Birthday of Thomas Jefferson: The Main Architect of Secularism for Our Global Village

5 Facts About Thomas Jefferson’s Faith

Book Review: Thomas Jefferson’s Qur’an: Islam and the Founders

Leave a Reply