Court rules Muslim doctor who refused to shake woman’s hand as she presented him with citizenship certificate has lost the right to become a German

  • The Lebanese man passed a citizenship test after living in Germany for 13 years 
  • But he failed at the final hurdle after refusing to shake the female official’s hand
  • State authorities denied him citizenship and a court has now upheld their ruling 

A Muslim doctor has been denied German citizenship after refusing to shake a woman’s hand when she gave him his certificate.

The 39-year-old Lebanese national was on the brink of becoming a German after living in the country for 13 years, completing his medical studies and passing a citizenship test with the highest possible mark.

But he failed at the final hurdle after refusing to shake the hand of the female official at the ceremony in 2015, leading state authorities to deny him citizenship.

Five years later, a court has backed their decision – saying the man’s ‘fundamentalist’ views were at odds with his integration into German society.

A Muslim doctor was denied German citizenship after refusing to shake hands with a female official at his naturalisation ceremony (stock photo)

A Muslim doctor was denied German citizenship after refusing to shake hands with a female official at his naturalisation ceremony (stock photo)

The man had moved to Germany in 2002 and lived there legally ever since, marrying a woman of Syrian origin about 10 years ago – promising her that he would never take the hand of another woman.

He started his application for citizenship in 2012 and signed the necessary paperwork vowing to uphold the constitution and reject extremism.

But the court in Mannheim said the handshake incident was incompatible with the constitution’s guarantee of equality between men and women.

‘If the applicant refuses to shake hands for gender-specific reasons which are incompatible with the constitution, there is no integration into German living conditions,’ they said.

‘This applies in particular if the refusal to shake hands with the opposite sex – as in this case – serves to further a Salafist conviction about the relationship between men and women.’

Germany has long held concerns about the fundamentalist Salafists, who make up only a tiny proportion of the country’s Muslim population.

The man’s refusal to shake hands with the official came from a belief that women posed a ‘threat of sexual temptation’, the court said.

Since the start of 2018, the man has stopped giving handshakes altogether – but the court dismissed this as a ‘tactical’ step to improve his chances of getting citizenship.

The court said that handshakes had deep roots in Western culture, including as a symbol of reaching agreement.

‘Handshakes are common greeting and farewell rituals that take place regardless of the social status, gender or other personal characteristics of the people involved and go back centuries,’ the judges said.

While other greetings such as kisses and high-fives are also available, they do not come with the came sense of formality and legal validity, the court said.

The judges also predicted that handshakes would withstand the coronavirus pandemic, in which physical touching has been kept to a minimum to reduce infections.

The man can now appeal the decision to a federal court.

source:

2 replies

  1. As now no-one is permitted to shake hands due to covid-19 will the appeals court approve his appeal?

    • This is so ridiculous, like France’s niqab ban but the public MUST put on the mask. Why are these people so intolerant of other cultures?

      How about Indians of whatever persuasion also don’t shake hands but join them in a ‘namaste’ gesture. Are the German authorities going to cancel their citizenship, too?!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.