Washington Post: Turkey’s political Islam?


(Repost  by Dr. H. Koya )

Opinion | In Turkey, political Islam is getting in the way of rational health policy

With its huge budget and staff, the decisions made by Turkey’s Religious Affairs Directorate (Diyanet) have had a negative effect on the country’s fight against the deadly coronavirus pandemic, exiled journalist Can Dündar wrote for the Washington Post.

“Over the past two weeks, Turkey has been witnessing a lethal tug of war between reason and belief — one that shows us again how dangerous politicized religion can be,” said Dündar, former editor-in-chief of opposition newspaper Cumhuriyet.

hagia-sophia-and-sultan-ahmet-mosque (1)

Blue mosque and Haagia Sophia in Istanbul. Suggested reading by the Muslim Times: When Not Going to Jumma is a Huge Blessing. The Muslim Times is promoting secularism in every country of the world

Diyanet officials participated in a meeting on Turkey’s response to the coronavirus, organised by Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan on March 18, while the country’s top medical professional organisation, the Turkish Medical Association (TTB) was not invited.

The top religious body had authorised thousands of Turks to go on pilgrimage to Mecca, Saudi Arabia, and by March 15 the 21,000 returning pilgrims became the biggest threat for the spread of the virus in Turkey as most of them were only checked for fevers at airports, against the advice of the TTB and other medical experts.

Only the last group of pilgrims, some 6,400 people, were quarantined, after many defied a non-binding request by the Diyanet to self-isolate for 14 days and not receive any visitors as is tradition.

“But it was too late,” Dündar said. “Thousands of people had spread across the country. Within a week, the number of cases surged from one to more than 1,000.”

Diyanet also decided to keep the mosques open, including for Friday prayers, “which draw around 18 million people each week,” Dündar said. The government suspended Friday prayers on March 16, later than many Islamic countries including Iran and Kuwait, and after entertainment and cultural venues were already closed.

“But it was too late again,” Dündar said. “Within one week, Turkey had surpassed all other countries in the rate of increase of cases.”

Following the meeting that included Diyanet and excluded the TTB, President Erdoğan “chose to speak like a cleric,” Dündar said, when he urged the country to “take precautions and leave judgement to Allah.”

“Our Lord’s help will be on our side,” Dündar quoted Erdoğan as saying on March 25, as the president responded to concerns raised by experts that the spread of the virus would accelerate in coming weeks due to the delayed initial reaction.

Religious talk dominated Turkish media rather than scientists, Dündar said. A sociology professor said the coronavirus was god’s wrath for “adultery and anal sex,” while an infectious disease expert from the Coronavirus Science Council said on live television that god created viruses for population control.

The pandemic has shown “just how the secular foundations of the education system have been eroded,” Dündar said, while Turkey’s economy faltered and healthcare system was “utterly unprepared for the challenge it faces.”

Religious authority has filled the gap the government created with the lack of “a serious, well-thought-out response,” with measures like mosques broadcasting prayers every night.

Political Islam in the country has obstructed science and misallocated vital resources, Dündar said, posing a direct threat to the nation’s health.

Suggested reading by Zia H Shah MD, Chief Editor of the Muslim Times

Corona Fear’s Cure: Chanting from the Bible and the Quran

UK coronavirus mass home testing to be made available ‘within days’

Praise be to God for the Miracle of Our Immune System

USA: 15-minute coronavirus test is here

The self isolation for 70 years and older may last up to 4 months

Does the Ordinary Soap Kill Coronavirus?

Islam: China has made eating wild animals illegal after the coronavirus outbreak?

All of humanity are intimate neighbors: Coronavirus proves it once again

Here’s a list of disinfectants you can use against coronavirus

To see the daily new cases and deaths in the top eleven countries go to

When Not Going to Jumma is a Huge Blessing

“We project that roughly 56 percent of our population – 25.5 million people – will be infected with the virus over an eight week period,” Governor Newsom of California wrote on 3/19/2020.

3 replies

  1. Let us see what will happen to Turkey—dose Allah will protect Muslim who went to pray in mosque?

    I agree with Imam Ahmadiyyah that congregation in Mosque and Meccah is dangerous Muslims do not need to pray in Mosque…. pray at home.

    • Somi Tempo,
      Assalamo Allaikum, deeply appreciate your comment.
      What Hazrat Khalifa Sahab said wasn’t something he cooked up. He cited narratives of the Holy Prophet Muhammad (Peace and the blessings of Allah be on him).
      Interesting, some Mullahs in Pakistan cites the sane Hadith to urge Muslims to pray at home when faced with unfavorable conditions.
      Definitely, Allah bless all those who comply with exhortations of His noble Prophet and verify His own commandments in the Holy Quran.
      Both of these combine helps at abide by ATTTIULLAH ATI UR RASOOL

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.