France, the way to Islamic reformation is to challenge institutions — not stigmatize Muslims

Hajj is a symbol of universal brotherhood and should help Muslims unite around human rights and walk away from divisions on petty theological details. The Muslim Times is refuting Islamism and promoting secularism in every country of the world

Source: Washington Post

By Ezzedine C. Fishere, who is a senior lecturer at Dartmouth College, where he has taught courses on Middle East politics and culture since 2016. He previously taught in the Political Science department of the American University in Cairo.

Earlier this month, French President Emmanuel Macron announced plans to regulate Islam in France and clamp down on so-called Islamic separatism. His statement drew criticism immediately, obscuring a deeper point. Recent events underscore the need for a reformed reading of Islam. But such reformation will not be brought about by stigmatizing Islam or Muslim communities, as the French president did. What is needed is to challenge Muslim institutions to take a clear position on Islamic jurisprudence justifying violence.

Macron’s speech of Oct. 2 wasn’t supposed to be a criticism of Islam. It was a policy statement about cracking down on “radical Islamist” influence among French Muslims to prevent their transformation into a “counter-republican” community. However, Macron’s bizarre remark that Islam “is in crisis all over the world today” unsurprisingly got most of the attention in the Middle East. The response was swift.

Countless voices in the Middle East and beyond decried French anti-Muslim bias, both now and during its colonial past, and warned that Macron’s remarks would trigger a far-right anti-Muslim backlash. Al-Azhar, Egypt’s leading religious authority, slammed Macron’s “racist” “hate speech” that will “inflame the feelings of two billion Muslim followers” around the world, and “block the path to constructive dialogue.” Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan didn’t miss the opportunity to belittle his French nemesis, with phrases such as “beyond disrespect,” “an open provocation” and “like a colonial governor.”

What was meant to be a debate about combating Islamic radicals in France turned into an outcry against “Macron’s stigmatization of Islam.” Nuanced Muslim voices got lost in the noise.

The Macron fiasco didn’t overshadow the problem of violence in the name of Islam for long. The beheading of a schoolteacher, Samuel Paty, on Oct. 16 for showing his students images of a caricature depicting Islam’s prophet came as a crude reminder of the problem. Calling it an isolated act, as the grand mufti of Egypt did, doesn’t cut it any longer. Nor does the lamentation over French atrocities in Algeria half a century ago. The problem of violence motivated by a certain interpretation of Islam is real.

Twenty-six years before Paty’s beheading, Nobel laureate Naguib Mahfouz narrowly escaped the same fate in Cairo for “insulting Islam” in one of his novels. The attacker who stabbed him was following a ruling by a leading Muslim cleric. Mahfouz and Paty are neither the first nor the last victims of this interpretation of Islam.

Read further

Dr. Zia H Shah, Chief Editor of the Muslim Times

Suggested reading by Zia H Shah MD, Chief Editor of the Muslim Times for understanding Islam for personal life and human rights for public life

Urdu Debate: Theocracy versus Democracy?

Must Watch Urdu Video: Secularism in Islam and rising above Sectarianism

Does UK Need a British Islam: BBC Big Questions Debate?

I came to a screeching halt when I saw a school bus rolling down
Is This Christian Shariah Law for USA?

Is God Alive or Dead: A Metaphor for the Scriptures from the US Constitution?

95 Years After the Monkey Trial, Tennessee Trying to Make the Bible the Official State Book

Ruth Bader Ginsburg Delivers Sharp Dissent In Supreme Court Cross Case

Reading the Quran and the Bible Literally Means Demons and Jinns Will Rule Humans

Allopathic Medicine’s long struggle with the Bible

Washington Post: Turkey’s political Islam?

Book Review: Muslims Learning Secularism from Jesus Son of Mary

Eating Beef in India; Another Reason Why World Needs Secularism in Our Global Village

The only constitution the world needs is the Universal Declaration of Human Rights

Book Review: The Tragic Illusion Of An Islamic State (The Tragic Illusion Of An Islamic State)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.