Identifying as Muslim On Resumes May Lead to Fewer Job Opportunities, Survey Says

(RNS) Recent college grads, take note: Mentioning a campus religion group on your resume — particularly a Muslim club — may lead to significantly fewer job opportunities.

Two new sociology studies find new graduates who included a religious mention on a resume were much less likely to hear back from potential employers.

The studies used fictitious resumes — with bland names that signaled no particular race or ethnicity. These were sent to employers who posted on the CareerBuilder website to fill entry-level job openings in sales, information technology and other fields suitable for first jobs out of college.

The researchers tested seven religious categories including: Roman Catholic, evangelical Christian, atheist, Jewish, Muslim, pagan, and one faith they just made up, “Wallonian,” to see what would happen compared to people who made no faith reference.

Fewer employers called back the “Wallonians,” as well as the others, reacting to “a fear of the unknown,” said University of Connecticut sociology professor Michael Wallace who led the studies.

In the South, where researchers sent 3,200 resumes, those with a religious mention got 29 percent fewer email responses and 33 percent fewer phone calls than otherwise identical resumes with no faith ties according to the study, released by the Southern Sociological Society on their Social Currents site.

Muslims faced the sharpest discrimination with 38 percent fewer emails and 54 percent fewer phone calls to the voice mailboxes set up by the researchers.

In New England, 6,400 applications were sent to 1,600 job postings by employers. But applications mentioning any religious tie were 24 percent less likely to get a phone call, according to the study published in Research in Social Stratification and Mobility.

Again, Muslims bore the brunt of discrimination, receiving 32 percent fewer emails and 48 percent fewer phone calls. Catholics were 29 percent less likely to get a call and pagans were 27 percent less likely — slightly better than the “Wallonian” applicants.

New Englander are a little more tolerant and they seemed not to care as much about religion. But in the South, the differences, particularly for applicants from minority religions show up more sharply, said Wallace.

While the study focused on entry-level jobs for new grads, Wallace said, “the bottom line message is that it is harmful to put it on your resume and this would relate to anybody at any point in their career.

“We have kind of a schizophrenic attitude toward religion in the U.S.,” he said. “We are a fairly religious country. We acknowledge religious freedom and religious diversity but at the same time, we don’t like it when religion is brought into public places such as the workplace or schools.”

Categories: Americas, United States

Tagged as: , , ,

2 replies

  1. My own experiences in job search was not negative as far as my religion is concerned. I did not put the religion on the CV, but with the names of ‘Mohammad Rafiq Ahmad Tschannen’ it was rather obvious anyway. When I was asked about my religion I used to answer that ‘in my job performance religion was often a positive aspect and never a negative aspect’. It was a positive aspect when working with Muslims or in Muslim countries and did not have any negative aspect anywhere else. I did hold a senior position in a Catholic outfit (Caritas) with its ultimate Headquarters in the Vatican. (The bishop of Kosovo did not object to me at the time, but did say after my departure that ‘I could never understand how Caritas could give Rafiq this position’. He said that to my successor. Rather ironic, because the guy went to Iran when there was an earthquake there, fell in love with a beautiful Iranian girl, changed his name to ‘Ali’ and married her. They have 3 beautiful children now, I understand. The bishop had nearly a heart attack probably, when my successor returned from Iran as ‘Ali’). Thanks to Allah for supporting me in my career …. Alhamdolillah …

Leave a Reply to Rafiq A. Tschannen Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.